October 9, 2026
This fall, some of the most interesting developments in the mass tort world are coming from an unlikely place: digital platforms, apps, and other 21st century technology. These cases are unique. Think about it. In these cases, the defendant does not commit the final bad act creating liability; a driver did, or a predator, or a stalker, or, in the new sports gambling cases, the user himself kept pressing the button. Plaintiffs’ arguments are becoming more familiar; the company built the system around the conduct, understood how people used it, and made profit-driven choices about safety and design. The Uber litigation started this trend. Now everybody wants a turn.
We’ve written plenty about Uber, so we will be brief. But I think we are headed towards some kind of resolution. On September 8, Judge Breyer expressly pushed the company toward broader settlement discussions, bluntly telling its lawyers that “Uber has to change its attitude. It’s not working.” The bellwethers explain some of the frustration. A Phoenix jury awarded Jaylynn Dean $8.5 million in February and declined punitive damages; a North Carolina jury found liability in April and awarded $5,000. This is technically data, but it’s extremely bad data (from a statistical perspective). Somewhere between $5,000 and $8.5 million may fit in a settlement matrix, but I would not volunteer to build it. We’ll learn more about that over the next several months.
Uber’s larger contribution may be the theory. The driver commits the assault but the company designed the platform, controlled access to riders, and made decisions about warnings, screening and safety. A third party does the terrible thing and the lawsuit depends on what the company knew about the traffic. And so far, courts have consistently found liability, even if the range is challenging.
The Meta litigation provided similar arguments and results. On August 18, a 6-week trial started, ending abruptly after eight days when Meta agreed to a settlement package worth approximately $18 billion. The agreement also imposes substantial protections for younger users. Eight days is not much of a trial, but it is one hell of an expensive focus group.
Predicting the future is trickier, but when the defendant is an app or website, these new theories start to look legitimate and powerful. Enter sports gambling. DraftKings and FanDuel are now facing a growing number of lawsuits based on similar theories as Uber and Meta. Plaintiffs say the problem is not just that gambling can be addictive. It is that the apps may know an awful lot about which customers are easiest to persuade, when they are most likely to bet again, and what kind of promotion is most likely to get them there. Imagine a bettor who gets crushed on Sunday night. The app knows when he plays, how often he deposits, what he bets, how much he loses, and which promotions have worked on him before. No one should call gambling addiction the next social-media mass tort yet. But the analogy no longer sounds crazy. If plaintiffs can ask what Meta knew about keeping a teenager scrolling at 1:00 am, somebody was inevitably going to ask what a sportsbook knows about keeping a losing bettor depositing at 1:00 am.
Roblox sits somewhere between Meta and Uber. Its federal child-sexual-exploitation MDL had 182 pending cases as of September 1. The cases allege that adult predators used Roblox and related platforms to contact, groom and exploit minors. Again, Roblox did not commit the underlying abuse. Instead, plaintiffs contend that platform design and safety failures helped create the opportunity. On September 23, Roblox and Discord asked the court to send bellwether claims to arbitration, arguing that the federal law permitting sexual-assault plaintiffs to escape forced arbitration does not reach claims against platforms accused of enabling third-party abuse. Before this litigation gets a damages bellwether, it may get a bellwether about whether the bellwether belongs in court at all. That’s a lot of bellwether.
I hate defense victories. But we have to talk about them. On September 1, in the first NEC bellwether trial, an Illinois jury found for Mead Johnson and rejected claims that Enfamil caused NEC in a premature infant who later died. Nearly 1,700 similar lawsuits are pending, more than 800 of them in the federal MDL. NEC previously produced enormous state-court plaintiff verdicts, including a $495 million Missouri verdict, which was ultimately settled on appeal. One defense verdict does not kill a tort. But it does dampen the mood around the party planning committee.
But it’s not all gloom and doom. The Bard PowerPort litigation gave plaintiffs exactly the opposite experience. On September 4, an Arizona jury awarded Kimberly Divelbliss $40 million (but no punitive damages) after finding Bard liable on design-defect and failure-to-warn theories involving a catheter that fractured and migrated into her heart. It was the first plaintiff verdict in the PowerPort MDL after the initial bellwether went Bard’s way. The next trials are scheduled for October 13, December 1 and February 2, 2027. So this case is heating up, and by winter, we may finally have something smart mass-tort lawyers treasure almost as much as fees: a pattern.
Roundup has reached the point where $7.25 billion is almost the easy part. Bayer has already spent billions resolving an earlier generation of Roundup cases, but roughly 65,000 claims remain pending in state and federal courts, principally from people who say Roundup exposure caused non-Hodgkin lymphoma. Nobody has been paid under this new deal yet. Monsanto is asking a Missouri court to approve a long-term settlement program that would cover those current claimants. Individual awards would generally range from about $10,000 to $165,000.
Talc requires an even greater feat of organization. On July 27, Johnson & Johnson announced a $5.5 billion settlement of nearly 76,000 remaining ovarian-cancer claims, but the deal requires participation by at least 95% of claimants. Ninety-five percent of 76,000 people agreeing to anything would be impressive. I am not sure 95% of 76,000 people could agree that Wednesday comes after Tuesday. The timing was not accidental. Just five days earlier, on July 22, the MDL ordered plaintiffs to explain why the remaining cases should not be dismissed over problems proving that J&J’s talc caused any particular claimant’s ovarian cancer. Then came the settlement. J&J maintains the claims lack scientific merit, but it has agreed to put serious money behind ending the fight. The first payment would be $3 billion in 2027, with additional payments in 2028. After years of trials, appeals and failed bankruptcy strategies, talc may finally be approaching an exit. It just needs almost everybody to take it.
Depo-Provera has already moved into the phase where you know a settlement is real because people with increasingly specialized titles begin appearing. Judge Rodgers appointed BrownGreer as settlement administrator on August 5. On September 4, she appointed an allocation master, a qualified-settlement-fund administrator and a lien-resolution master. At some point a mass tort ceases to resemble litigation and starts developing its own civil service. (Craig’s note – we have a very strong Facebook funnel for depo provera – all our depo cases come with proof of brain meningioma diagnosis)
Paraquat remains more mysterious. The settlement terms are confidential, but some lawyers following the litigation are saying average MDL recoveries could land around $100,000 to $110,000, while cautioning that stronger cases may be worth more. We’re guessing. Nobody outside the deal knows what the average claim in the settlement pool looks like. That is not an official number. It is market chatter. (Craig’s note – we’re also currently running Paraquat but we are booked solid and cannot accept new budget at this time. However we have capacity for both Chlorpyrifos and Atrazine.)
Camp Lejeune has spent years being enormous without doing the one thing litigation is supposedly designed to do: actually have a trial. That changes in November. As of September 18, DOJ reported more than $1.1 billion in Camp Lejeune settlement offers and more than $879 million accepted and paid. Now Judge Boyle has scheduled the first two kidney-cancer bench trials: Mousser on November 9 and Fancher on November 16. Both will be tried without juries. More than 23,000 Camp Lejeune claimants allege kidney cancer, so these are two cases that implicate much more than 2 plaintiffs. Judges overseeing the litigation have directed leadership counsel to work toward a broader settlement by October 30, with the November trials arriving almost immediately afterward. Nothing improves the quality of settlement discussions quite like a trial judge checking his calendar.
Summer is when new torts look exciting. Fall is when they start showing their work. For plaintiff firms, that means knowing when a case has moved from interesting to investable. A $40 million PowerPort verdict can change intake overnight. So can an NEC defense win. An $18 billion Meta settlement can make an adjacent theory suddenly look a lot less theoretical. There will always be another “next Roundup.” The trick is figuring out which cases still look good after the leaves start falling.
Our Meta Facebook campaigns are a great way to find claimants. Everything is done for you from start to finish: advertising, intake, signing and verification.
Agency Model (percent of spend) – cost varies, but often more cost-effective. You own all leads and control the creative, messaging, and branding. Unlike other agencies, we include a bundled legal intake center that calls leads back in under 1 minute.
Fixed-Price Model – A predictable cost per qualified, signed retainer. If we don’t deliver, you’re refunded.

Craig H. Alinder, Vice President
Office: 802-664-4201 | Email: craig@legalcalls.com
Legal Calls, 2108 N Street, Suite 4809, Sacramento, CA 95816, (877) 853-5801